The Haredi Parties’ Political Dilemma
They might topple the government over conscription, but they’re unlikely to find better options.
June 10, 2025
And tried to end elected officials’ control of the police.
Part of what brought about the current impasse involving haredi conscription was a Supreme Court ruling eight years ago, which invalidated a possible legislative solution, and split the right. The court, the subject of so much political controversy before the war began, recently issued two more seminal rulings, which were easy for those following Israeli news from abroad to have missed. In one, the court invalidated the government’s decision to fire the head of the Shin Bet, essentially placing the internal security agency beyond civilian control. The second, which got little attention even from Israelis, also concerns the appointment of personnel. Yonatan Green explains the intricacies of both rulings and their implications for the future of Israeli democracy in conversation with Aylana Meisel-Diament. (Video, 51 minutes. Audio is available on podcast platforms.)
They might topple the government over conscription, but they’re unlikely to find better options.
And tried to end elected officials’ control of the police.
A new era for religious schools is arriving.
Actual genocides in Rwanda, Sudan, and elsewhere got no such coverage.
Documenting and preserving the culture of East European Jewry.
Part of what brought about the current impasse involving haredi conscription was a Supreme Court ruling eight years ago, which invalidated a possible legislative solution, and split the right. The court, the subject of so much political controversy before the war began, recently issued two more seminal rulings, which were easy for those following Israeli news from abroad to have missed. In one, the court invalidated the government’s decision to fire the head of the Shin Bet, essentially placing the internal security agency beyond civilian control. The second, which got little attention even from Israelis, also concerns the appointment of personnel. Yonatan Green explains the intricacies of both rulings and their implications for the future of Israeli democracy in conversation with Aylana Meisel-Diament. (Video, 51 minutes. Audio is available on podcast platforms.)
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe Now