Carrots, Not Sticks, Are the Way to Bring Conscription to Israel’s Arabs and Ultra-Orthodox
Israel doesn’t need more soldiers; it needs more integration.
March 13, 2018
Israel doesn’t need more soldiers; it needs more integration.
Israel’s governing coalition narrowly avoided collapse this past weekend over the objections of ḥaredi members to legislation that would increase the number of ultra-Orthodox Jews serving in the IDF. Yet the underlying problem is more widespread than that. Currently, notes Yoaz Hendel, only 50 percent of young Israelis enter the military:
Get the best Jewish ideas and conversations. Subscribe to Tikvah Ideas All Access for $12/month
Login or SubscribeIsrael doesn’t need more soldiers; it needs more integration.
Defeat in war, not outside mediation, is usually what prompts negotiation.
Perhaps it was shamed by the Arab states.
Neither can the Congressional Black Caucus.
Having a Jewish grandmother didn’t stop Hildebrand Gurlitt from becoming the Nazis’ favorite art dealer.