Refugees, the Holocaust, and the Danger of Illiterate and Partisan Analogies
Hitler, not FDR, caused the Holocaust. American isolationism, not refugee policy, helped him do it.
January 30, 2017
Forcing Palestinians to acknowledge Israel’s historical claim to the land would provide them with an honorable basis for compromise.
For decades, the American government has implicitly and explicitly adopted the Arab narrative about the Palestinians. Thus, ranking U.S. officials have spoken as if Jews and Palestinians have equal claim to Jerusalem, refused to admit that west Jerusalem is Israel’s capital (or even part of Israel), pretended that the “right of return” of Palestinian “refugees” (really the descendants of refugees) is seriously up for negotiation, and acted as if Palestinian society or its leadership is sincerely interested in peace. Max Singer argues that Washington can do much good by insisting on the truth:
Get the best Jewish ideas and conversations. Subscribe to Tikvah Ideas All Access for $12/month
Login or SubscribeHitler, not FDR, caused the Holocaust. American isolationism, not refugee policy, helped him do it.
The idea that Jews have somehow made unfair “use” of the Holocaust.
Forcing Palestinians to acknowledge Israel’s historical claim to the land would provide them with an honorable basis for compromise.
The Jewish itch to believe in universal substitutes for Judaism.
Romans, not Jews.