Tikvah
Subscribe

Edward Rothstein


Edward Rothstein is Critic at Large at the Wall Street Journal. His essays in Mosaic include “The Problem with Jewish Museums,” “Jerusalem Syndrome at the Met,” and “The Unusual Relationship Between Abraham Lincoln and the Jews.”

Latest Content

  1. Response ·

    The Messages about Jews in Christian Art

    By Edward Rothstein

    The letter “I” that begins the Latin translation of the first book of the Hebrew Bible is shaped by an unusual series of illuminations in the 13th-century Abbey Bible from Bologna, Italy. The letter’s...

    The Messages about Jews in Christian Art
  2. Editor's Pick ·

    Like 9/11, 10/7 Has Only Strengthened Intellectuals’ Commitment to Make Excuses for Terrorism

    Anything done to the Jews in Israel will be justified.

  3. Editor's Pick ·

    Maimonides at the Museum

    The Golden Path.

  4. Response ·

    Hollywood’s Retreat into Universalism

    By Edward Rothstein

    Why do they hate us? And what are we going to do about it? Those questions were asked a lot in the United States in the years after 9/11. They have also been asked a lot by Jews over many, many more y...

    Hollywood’s Retreat into Universalism
  5. Editor's Pick ·

    Jews’ Sense of Themselves Flies in the Face of Today’s Identity Politics

    The Jewish story of redemption doesn’t just involve enduring suffering, but actually imposes obligations.

  6. Editor's Pick ·

    A New Exhibit Exchanges the Story of Art Plundered by the Nazis for Banalities

    Afterlives treats history as if it were a burden.

  7. Editor's Pick ·

    Now Online, Recordings of the Nuremberg Trials Make Evil Sound Dull

    Even though it never is.

  8. Response ·

    The Dismantling of Jewish Identity

    By Edward Rothstein

    The scandal of the Jewish Museum in New York, as Menachem Wecker’s fine essay shows, is a scandal caused by immense curatorial ignorance, both cultural and religious, combined with the arrogant beli...

    The Dismantling of Jewish Identity
  9. Editor's Pick ·

    An “Unmissable” Exhibit on Auschwitz Falls into the Familiar Trap of Universalizing the Holocaust

    Oddly discomfited by the Jewish center of the story it tells, and overly content with contemporary platitudes.

  10. Response ·

    Biblical Illiteracy = Cultural Illiteracy

    By Edward Rothstein

    Can a leopard change its spots? Is anything new under the sun? How have the mighty fallen? Is there a phrase in the English language that has not been shaped by translations of the Hebrew Bible (Tan...

    Biblical Illiteracy = Cultural Illiteracy
  11. Editor's Pick ·

    “Indecent” Tells a False Story about a Yiddish Drama

    Misreading God of Vengeance.

  12. Editor's Pick ·

    The Metropolitan Museum’s Fictitious Golden Age of Jerusalem

    Jerusalem syndrome.

  13. Response ·

    Not “Your” City—”Everyone’s” City

    By Edward Rothstein

    Last fall, the art historian Victoria C. Gardner Coates published an op-ed article in the Wall Street Journal suggesting that the utopian multicultural paradise imagined by the Metropolitan Museum o...

    Not “Your” City—”Everyone’s” City
  14. Monthly Essay ·

    Jerusalem Syndrome at the Met

    By Edward Rothstein

    An exhibition on the diverse multiculturalism of medieval Jerusalem has been ecstatically received. There's just one problem: the vision of history it promotes is a myth.

    Jerusalem Syndrome at the Met
  15. Editor's Pick ·

    A Full-Scale Replica of Noah’s Ark May Fail by Not Taking the Bible Literally Enough

    Adrift on a flood of speculation.

  16. Editor's Pick ·

    Anti-Semitism Is Not Like Other Forms of Prejudice

    From Berlin then to Oberlin now.

  17. Response ·

    How Jewish Museums Reflect the Condition of Mainstream Jews

    By Edward Rothstein

    Why are there Jewish museums? And what are they meant to accomplish? Among the many issues raised by the generous and thoughtful responses to my essay by Diana Muir Appelbaum , Walter Reich , and...

    How Jewish Museums Reflect the Condition of Mainstream Jews
  18. Monthly Essay ·

    The Problem with Jewish Museums

    By Edward Rothstein

    Ours is an era of museums celebrating the identity of nearly every group and ethnicity. But something else takes place when the identity in question is Jewish.

    The Problem with Jewish Museums
  19. Observation ·

    In What Way Is This Music Jewish?

    By Charles Krauthammer, Edward Rothstein

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

    In What Way Is This Music Jewish?
  20. Observation ·

    Unknown Musicians of a Wandering Race

    By Edward Rothstein

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

    Unknown Musicians of a Wandering Race
  21. Editor's Pick ·

    Islamist Iconoclasm and Its Imperial Aims

    On the destruction of ancient artworks.

  22. Observation ·

    The Unusual Relationship Between Abraham Lincoln and the Jews

    By Edward Rothstein

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

    The Unusual Relationship Between Abraham Lincoln and the Jews
  23. Response ·

    Something More Profound than Prejudice

    By Edward Rothstein

    Reading Nathan Shields’ powerful essay, “Wagner and the Jews,” reawakened memories from two decades ago when I attended the Bayreuth festival as a music critic. My most potent recollections are not of...

    Something More Profound than Prejudice
  24. Editor's Pick ·

    When Defamatory Politics Masquerade as Art

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

  25. Editor's Pick ·

    Natural Disaster

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

  26. Editor's Pick ·

    Sailing Away on Noah’s Ark

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

  27. Editor's Pick ·

    Exhibitionism

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.

  28. Editor's Pick ·

    Beyond the Secret Annex

    Committed to developing and supporting the intellectual, religious, and political leaders of the Jewish people and the Jewish state.